Homepage / Content Marketing / Should Marketing Be Held To A Higher Standard Than Engineering?
Three Important Words That Don’t Make Craft Beer Taste Better Specialty Coffee’s Focus Problem Brand New Layout Coffee Spanish for Coffee Buyers – A Field Guide Coffee Spanish for Coffee People Book – Kickstarter final week! Hungry People Don’t Stay Hungry For Long You Can Never Be Safe. Data Always Lies Fresh Start Toy 11 Seconds of Parasitic Sucking How Do You Know What Customers Want? How Much Is Your Vote Worth? Sometimes in Writing It’s The Mechanics of Writing, Rather Than The Glory of Writing Some Poetry and Prose to Enhance the Soul. What Does The Average American’s Inability To Merge Mean For Society At Large? Hunter vs. Farmer: The Mighty Coffee Hunter vs The Dirty Hands Coffee Farmer In Defense of Friendly Coffee Gimme Back My Lunch Money! Rock Gods Never Die. David Bowie is Forever. Customers Don’t Exist Stumptown Coffee Plus Peet’s Coffee – Welcome To Peetstown Depth. Majesty. Silence so Loud it Roars.  Is Craft Coffee a Bloody Triangle or a Balanced Square? 12 Tiny Steps To Make Your Daily Coffee a More Eco-Friendly Experience Should You Give The Customer What They Want? Love In The Key of Coffee Misfits, Punks, Dreamers and Diamonds – 11 years of Passion Poured By People Every Coffee Has A Home. Yet Not Every Home Has Coffee. Perfect Example of The Roles of Engineering and Marketing 30 By 30, Writing 30 Posts In 30 Days And Liking It Hands Dirty and Knee Deep in the Messy, Risky Act of Creation The All Epic Epicness of Being- Why You Shouldn’t Do What We Did Luck : Were You Born With It Or Was It Mabeline? Can You Hire an Entrepreneur? The Great And Mighty Why The Marketing Pyramid of Radness The Perfect Pitch – Can You Really Get VC Laid In An Elevator? The Duplicitous Dichotomy of Divergence and the Brand Zombie Apocalypse Is There A Difference In B2B & B2C Marketing Strategies? Or Is It All H2H? All You Have To Do Is Think Like An Employee. (So We’re Screwed.) Just Because it’s Valuable Doesn’t Mean It’s Not Spam. Is Marketing Promotion, Product or Purpose? Stuck in the 90’s – San Diego Radio is Stupid The Day I Realized I Was A Writer Should Marketing Be Held To A Higher Standard Than Engineering? Will iBeacons Steal Your Soul or Save Your Life? If Money Is Not the Object, What Is? Impoverished Frugality – The Essence of Not Winning Don’t Growth Hack Me Bro! The Dreaded Passive Voice- Why Shame Should Be Felt When Passive Bombs Are Dropped 8 Stunning Things You May Not Know About My Wife – But After 25 Years of Marriage, I Do Why Bud Light Drinkers Are More Beer Snobs Than I Am Post It and They Will Come. Content Marketing, Writing and Cameron Diaz Twitter Chats FTW – Why You Should Join The Conversation Non Veni, Et Vidi, Vici – The Not Being There of the Modern Marketer Turns Out, When You Go To a Bar or Restaurant You Bring Your SmartPhone The 4 Essential Social Media Tools That Rock Big Idea Generation Machine – Shower or Sleep? 30 Posts in 30 Days – Writing Like A Whirlwind 304 Of My Favorite Social Media Tools All On One Massive List.ly List SocialMediaToday – 3 Simple Ways to Increase Your Email Open Rates in Under an Hour SocialMediaToday – 5 Things I Wish Everyone Knew About Email Marketing Killer Tacos + Social Customer Care = Rock My World A Collective New Media Genius Staggering to Behold Wonderfully Refreshing Use of an Infographic to Drive Engagement Extreme B2B Crowdsourcing & Marketing Done Right Entrepreneurs Are Lazy Workaholics When Can SEO Finally Die? Email Growth Hacks for Successful Marketers Growth Hacking- Reducing Friction < Improving Slide Freshie Fresherton – Social Fresh Top 43 Career Moves of 2013 Art of War- Competitive Intelligence As An Offensive Weapon Sauces and Soups, Is Your Marketing Feeding Your Customers? Why is HR Not Part of Marketing Already? Laser or Discoball: Can You Sum Up What Your Company Does in 140 Characters? Hey, Can You Pass the Secret Sauce? The Rise of the Content Machine – You Will Be Assimilated and Like It 4 Takeaways, 50 Hot Cars and 1 Zombie Survival Marketing is a Hardcore Disciplinarian – And It Does Not Take Lip Service Welcome to the Mobile Revolution. The Battle is Over, Mobile Won. San Diego Craft Beer Week Explodes With Awesomeness Engaged Employees Build Engaged Customers – Technorati Feature 5 Key Takeaways from the Lifecycle Messaging Conference #LCMC13 Is Your Facebook Page a Photo Dump Truck? Reality Social Media- The King of Andy’s Glasses Flip The Script On Your Eyes – Warby Parker Gets All Customer Love on You Social Media Platforms- Twitter is The Heart & Soul They Named a Lucha Libre Tournament After My Wife Content Schmontent – We Don’t Want Your Stinkin’ Content Marketing The 8 Key Strategy Insights From Social Fresh Social Media Strategy = Achieving Business Objectives #SocialFresh West Finale Day 2- The Brainsplosion of Goodness Social Fresh West Conference Day 1- Social Power Overload Social Fresh Conference = Awesomepants! The Facebook ~ Twitter Autopost Conundrum Social Fresh West 2013- San Diego Give ’em What You Do Best Social Media Voice Branding Tip: We Like Impersonal Pronouns

Content Marketing, Entrepreneurial Tendencies, Marketing Strategy

Should Marketing Be Held To A Higher Standard Than Engineering?

startup marketing strategies

Should marketing work product: blog posts, tweets, webpages, PR, product descriptions, onboarding, customer service, tag-lines, logos, articles, influencer marketing, case studies and all the other 1,000 marketing things we do be held to a higher standard of perfection than the engineering work product: software code, hardware, and UI? In other words which disciplines work product has a greater negative affect when it’s not perfect?

Part of the argument centers around the impact of less than perfect work product and how easy it is to fix versus how much of a negative it is when it’s wrong. A core tenet of smart, modern marketing and engineering teams is the idea that:

This is a pretty radical approach. It started with the lean and agile style software development teams and morphed into the concept of minimum viable product (MVP) and lean startup. In other words do the absolutely bare minimum work to get the absolute bare minimum product into the hands of the potential customers as fast as possible. This is predicated on the idea that the vast majority of startups have no earthly idea what they are trying to do or what their business model is going to be. They have lots of ideas of course but ideas don’t make a business. 

Even product/market fit does not make a business. Only a business makes a business.

startup marketing strategies

Which of the two gets the raw end of the stick? Marketing or engineering?

In my experience with a wide variety of businesses I have found that there is an inordinate level of scrutiny and pressure on the marketing work product that goes far beyond the level of scrutiny and input over the engineering work product. Not to say that no one cares when engineering screws up, but there are some striking differences in how the two products are judged. Although there is almost always a much higher pressure level put on engineering teams in development cycles. This is not what I am talking about. I am talking about when other people in the company, who are NOT on your team, look at your work product ow do they judge it? How do they judge mistakes or imperfections? Why do they treat them differently?

startup marketing strategies

 

 

I think the differences come down to two simple things:

  • Marketing FEELS subjective but SEEMS objective
  • Engineering SEEMS objective but FEELS subjective

And further differences in how the two disciplines are perceived:

  • Most executives in most companies feel they understand marketing very well
  • Most executives don’t value marketing very highly as it is seen as touchy-feely
  • Most executives believe that marketing is a necessary evil
  • Most executives in most companies do not understand engineering well
  • Most executives feel that engineering is objective and cut and dry
  • Most executives believe that engineering is basically magic since they don’t understand it

In other words most business people feel they understand marketing, think its easy to do and that it is very subjective. However most executives don’t truly understand marketing so they focus on the low hanging, unripe fruit of punctuation, spelling, pixel borders, image size, logo placement and other subjective (but seemingly objective) things. That way they can be shown to have strong opinions, caught errors, made an impact and ‘did marketing’.

Those same executives absolutely do NOT understand engineering and are frustrated and confused by engineers and their high-faluttin’ words and technical jargon. Since they don’t understand what the hell engineering does let alone how they do it they trust them to do their job. Compound this with the widespread belief that engineering is purely objective when it’s clearly got a LOT of subjectivity and you have a strong mixture that is designed to give engineering immense leeway.

These ideas are dangerous and build in disaster to organizations. Obviously there are many, many companies who do not operate like this, but far more that do.

My main question is:

If the concept of MVP is the GOAL, not just the acceptable, then why so the vast majority of companies hold marketing output to the higher standard of Maximum Perfect Product? I am NOT advocating for spelling, punctuation or other easy to make and even easier to fix mistakes in any discipline. I am advocating for a wider understanding that just like in engineering marketing too has an MVP goal and that done is better than perfect.

How long will your customers remember that time you did not put an Oxford comma after the and in that tweet last month? How long will those same customers remember the time engineering put a tiny little bug in the code that lost them a weeks worth of data and cost them money?

Which one will cause you to lose more customers?

Should BOTH be held to the same standard of perfection (or lack thereof) or should one have higher standards of perfection it is held to?

2 Comments

  1. Pingback: Is Marketing Promotion, Product or Purpose? | The Great StrategeryThe Great Strategery

  2. Pingback: Is Marketing Promotion, Product or Purpose? | News Feed

Thoughts and Counter Thoughts?

%d bloggers like this: